Comparison Of Two Planning Approach In Transportation Tourism Essay

The chief intent of this paper is to discourse two paradigms- Rational comprehensive planning attack and Advocacy be aftering attack with respect to the subject transit planning. Transportation be aftering history in the U.S. has been a rational comprehensive planning attack. Later protagonism and communicative action planning attacks besides came into drama to turn to environmental concerns, conurbation and equity issues caused by transit. Harmonizing to the U.S. Federal Law, metropolitan countries with a population of more than 50,000 must hold a metropolitan transit program. This program is a design of long scope multimodal comprehensive transit planning. In this paper, I will concentrate on rational and protagonism planning attacks for Transportation Planning on vicinity and metropolitan degree by comparing the comparative drawbacks and virtues of these two different attacks through the selected instance surveies.

In the history of the U.S. , the early 50 ‘s and 60 ‘s saw a major alteration in the mentality of be aftering procedure. The rational procedure of planning and the system position of be aftering emerged in response to the 1960s physical planning due to societal sightlessness, Utopian planning and their design nature. The early physical planning was criticized for non being cognizant of the world of populating infinite. It is criticized that “ contrivers did non grok the apprehension of the relationship between societal planning and physical planning ” ( Kaplan, 1964 ) . Therefore there was a societal sightlessness among contrivers. Peoples were displaced from industrial topographic points to suburbs. Planing radius for the helpers instead than talking for the multitudes. Planing became the province ‘s map. Government took charge of pull offing lands. There was attempt to pull off economic system through authorities investings.

During the station World War II everything was viewed through the political orientation of scientific discipline. However, planning was considered as both scientific discipline and researchable. Peoples were more interested in the ‘process ‘ and ‘how ‘ so whole planning system was undergoing a alteration. As a consequence of these unfavorable judgments and populace ‘s involvement of cognizing the procedure, new be aftering theories were developed. These new developed theories, one being the rational planning attack, were described to be proficient, abstract and extremely mathematical.

Rational Planning:

The rational theory, which embarked the matrimony of scientific discipline with policy both in national and local degrees, made contrivers psychologically safe to heighten their qualitative research scheme to roll up equal information in understanding the modern-day issues, puting the ends to work out jobs and warranting recommendations to make the agencies. Rational planning approached jobs from an incorporate position point, utilizing conceptual or mathematical theoretical accounts that relate aims to resources and restraints with heavy trust on Numberss and quantitative analysis ( Hudson, 1979 ) . A general rational planning procedure involved the stairss of specifying a job, placing options, measuring options, implementing programs and policies and supervising their effects. The rational planning theory had a certain methodological analysis that could be applied to smaller jobs and in a modified signifier. This planning assumed that a community ‘s assorted corporate ends can be measured in some effectual manner ( Altshuler, 1965 ) . The method strived to be nonsubjective, proficient, and exclude subjective and emotional treatment sparked by divergent perceptual experience of job ( Taylor, 1998 ) .

Criticisms of Rational Planning

Rational planning, besides known as procedural planning theory, was the dominant planning pattern after the Second World War until it was criticized in the 1970s. It has been criticized for its inability to authenticate the empirical analysis of societal and economic aims, test ‘good policy ‘ and warrant ‘means and terminals ‘ relationships. The unfavorable judgment of the rational planning theory are two creases. First of wholly, it was criticized for being ‘content lupus erythematosus and empty ‘ because it specifies merely thought and moving processs that underestimate human-beings and overestimate professional information and cognition. Besides, the rational contrivers analyze jobs abstractly, narrowly and superficially taking to the exclusion of societal conditions from be aftering procedure. Second, it was criticized for being a theoretical account of rational decision-making instead than a theoretical account of rational-action. The rational procedure really gave small attending to the inquiry of how programs and policies get implemented. Harmonizing to ( Friedmann, 1971 ) , the rational procedure has linear phases where execution comes in the ulterior portion of the planning procedure. It lacks communicating and dialogue during the procedure. Plan execution is ever debatable and execution jobs are unpredictable. Execution requires communicating accomplishments and interpersonal dealingss. Therefore to get the better of the spread between decision-making and execution, a new planning attack is needed that would integrate interpersonal communicating and dialogue in the plan-making and execution procedure.

Simon and March reviews of determination doing procedure in Rational Planning are that it is equivocal, contrivers consider themselves to be good informed but in fact they are non ( Froster, 1989 ) . Its demands are considerable and require more than decision-makers are capable of giving. The impossibleness of foretelling all effects or hold on all variables and the deficiency of resources and clip to roll up information needed for rational pick bound its practicableness ( Etzioni, 1973 ) . Lindblom farther notes that the costs of being more comprehensive frequently exceeded the benefits ( Lindblom, 1959 ) .

Current Scenario:

Despite many unfavorable judgments and development of other be aftering attacks, the pattern of rational planning is still prevailing in the planning sphere. The benefit-cost analysis which is widely used for the executing of assorted undertakings is a major portion of the procedural rational planning procedure. The experts, who have knowledge of quantitative analysis, accomplishments in proficient problem-solving, and other analytical accomplishments, work as rational contrivers. Due to the handiness of specialised practicing contrivers, the rational planning is still prevailing in the market.

Paradigm 2: Advocacy planning

Rise of Advocacy Planning

Rise of protagonism planning was to some extent a failure of rational planning in turn toing the planning jobs. The rational planning theory which switched be aftering from ends-oriented to means-oriented became a portion of authorities maps. It claimed to be scientific, rationalist, value free, with no personal involvement and free from political relations. The rational contrivers who claimed themselves as social-servants and work in the public-sphere focused on end preparation through program rating to acquire the ideal consequence. These rational contrivers served as the techno-professionals and used their personal cognition and accomplishments in planning. Different techniques such as cost-benefit analysis and Lichfield ‘s technique yielded the most ideal consequence. In the 1960s, the main roads in urban countries were built utilizing the method of ‘cost-benefit analysis, ‘ which subsided societal values and replaced the countries of hapless people for main roads. The value measuring was in favour of certain societal groups ‘ involvements. This shows that be aftering determinations were politically influenced pretermiting the most deprived. Harmonizing to Paul Davidoff “ Planning determinations were influenced by political guidance ; they seem to be pretermiting the most deprived ” ( Davidoff, 2003 ) . Rational planning, which is supposed to be scientific and free of political relations and values neither gave justified solution nor gave an ideal reply. Therefore, there was a demand of knowing contrivers, trained leaders and advocators of assorted involvement groups who could play dynamic function in making a better environment and who can integrate maximal public engagement for impartial consequence. This demand gave rise to new type of be aftering which is called protagonism planning. Advocacy planning, as initiated by Davidoff, is an effort to integrate the voices or values that would non otherwise be represented by the incremental attack. Through protagonism planning, contrivers can recommend the involvements of those who are out-of-reach and powerless to stand for their ain involvements. Therefore, protagonism planning is a representation of certain societal groups by protagonism contrivers, utilizing the applied techniques of jurisprudence.

In protagonism planning, public involvement is ‘plural ‘ instead than ‘unitary ‘ . Advocacy contrivers organize different charrettes in order to include public engagement and seek audience throughout the planning procedure. They besides pattern inclusive pluralism which includes all racial groups, low income groups and minorities. In add-on, they value-laden judgement as portion of the determination devising and planning devising procedure.

Criticisms of Advocacy Planning

The major unfavorable judgment of protagonism planning was that contrivers shifted their concerns and be aftering penchant from one group of people to another while practising inclusive pluralism. This planning attack was besides criticized for being top-down attack with an engagement of outside experts in public engagement and audience. Even though protagonism planning favored the disadvantaged group, it wholly ignored the other groups. Furthermore, protagonism planning goes non travel into the poverty issue in deepness, it merely temporarily provides solution.

Case study 1: The Chicago Area Transportation Study

This instance survey illustrates executing of the rational planning theoretical account during the late fiftiess and early sixtiess for Chicago Metropolitan Area. The survey theoretical account outlined in 10 stairss shows the rational ways of planning and its effectivity in act uponing determinations.

Location and Background:

This instance survey of Chicago country Transportation Study ( CATS ) has been considered as a benchmark for most of the transit undertakings. Before this instance survey, main road planning used to be performed at corridor degree. Fifty five old ages ago, the largest transit study of all time was conducted in the survey country of CATS. The chief aim of the study was to fix a information necessary for the Chicago Area Transportation Study. Detroit Metropolirtan Area traffic survey, started in 1953, is considered to be first comprehensive metropolitan country transit survey. CATSA, formed in 1955, is a 2nd 1. The survey focused chiefly on trip distribution, traffic assignment, and cost benefit analysis. Since it acted as an impromptu bureau, it had a duty of be aftering side but non the execution portion. It took seven old ages to finish with a entire outgo of $ 3,500,000 in the whole procedure.

The Ten Step Rational Model:

Harmonizing to ( Black, 1990 ) the whole survey can be categorized in 10 additive stairss. Out of 10 stairss, two or more stairss can be performed at the same time. If any mistakes are encountered during the procedure, amendments can be done by reiterating the earlier stairss. The stairss performed are explained below:

Data Collection: It is the largest phase of the survey. Since the informations aggregation phase needed tonss of work force which was around 368 staffs, the outgo was besides really high around more than a million dollar. These staffs collected informations of the full survey part with country of 1,236 square stat mis and population of 5.2 million. Data aggregation was based on study done through personal interview. The interview was conducted to 50,000 families with a ratio of one in 30 samples. Land usage of the full survey country was categorized into six types which are residential, fabrication, transit, commercial, public edifices and public unfastened infinite based on Aerial Image. For those countries covered under Sunborn Company maps, “ measuring and categorization of the floor country was done based on Standard Industrial categorization ” ( J.R & A ; Sharkey, 1960 ) . Inventories of bing main road and public theodolite paths facilitated the transit system study.

Analysis of informations: It was one of the longest parts of the procedure. The best result of this procedure was the measuring of relationship between trips and land usage. This new find thrilled everyone involved in the procedure.

Forecasting the future context: CATS devoted major attempt in land usage projection, prognosis for future trip devising, manner of travel for mark twelvemonth 1980. As portion of the procedure, it developed a prognosis of economic activity by 50 sectors input end product theoretical account. Harmonizing to Plummer ‘s study, “ CATS predicted a 50 per centum addition in population and a doubling of rider vehicles to suit an 80 % addition in vehicle stat mis traveled by 1980 ” ( Plummer, 2005 ) . The prognosis showed the people utilizing the public theodolite is merely 25 per centum of the people utilizing different manners of transit ; nevertheless it could merely be merely 14 per centum if entire figure of trips made by public theodolite remained changeless for 1980. The CATS was criticized for its land usage prognosis for being an extrapolation of future tendencies instead than a program.

Establishing ends: After doing the prognosis based on the collected information analysis, Dr Carroll and Creigton, managers of CATS, drafted and discussed these six ends with the reding commission.

Greater Speed

Increased Safety

Lower operation cost

Economy in new building

Minimizing break

Promoting better land development

Design Alternatives: In this measure, contrivers designed several surrogate ways to accomplish ends. CATS assessed tonss of options for each traffic constituents. Of the several options, grid Fe was favored over radial-circumferential ( or cobweb ) form. The ground for taking grid Fe was that it would scatter the traffic where as in radial-circumferential form ; it would perchance constellate the traffic and hence cause traffic congestion at the centre. Under this phase, tonss of theodolite webs and alternate main road webs were designed and tested to acquire the ideal consequence.

Testing Options: This procedure is besides known as gauging impacts. It frequently utilizes mathematical and computational theoretical accounts. CATS developed a methodological analysis known as four measure travel demand prediction, this formed the footing for most of the travel demand and land usage theoretical accounts up to day of the month. The four stairss were carried out in following order:

Trip Coevals: A relationship formed on the BASIC of additive arrested development between land usage and trip coevals in 1956 study was used to gauge 1980 trip coevals from each zones.

Modal Split: Trips in each zone was divided in ratio of people utilizing public conveyance and private auto for base twelvemonth and the ratio was used for jutting twelvemonth computation.

Trip Distribution: This was a type of aggregative theoretical account where it considered all the trips that would get down or stop at centroid of that zone. This measure besides involved the development of beginnings and finishs utilizing gravitation theoretical account or chance theoretical account.

Traffic Assignment: This measure estimated path of each path utilizing “ minimal way algorithms. ” The appraisal was based on the computation of optimum path from beginning to finish which would minimise entire travel cost. By this manner peak clip traffic volume were estimated in each path.

Evaluation of options: As options, four types of cost were estimated for the intent of benefit cost analysis. The alternate estimated costs were travel clip, accident, operation and building cost. All these cost were assigned numeral values and measured in dollars.

Choice of one option: Choice of the best option would depend on the determination shapers as contrivers ‘ functions are consultative. The policy commission approved plan L-3 and theodolite program. Plan L-3 covered 520 stat mis of freeway. The theodolite program recommended building of one new rail line and extension of three of three bing lines, building of parking garages of outer terminus of rail theodolite.

Execution: Cat was merely responsible for supplying the program. It had no execution power and was merely an reding organic structure to its sponsoring bureaus the metropolis, county, province and federal authorities.

Monitoring: It is besides known as feedback measure. CATS performed this measure really good. It produced studies comparing original prognosis with updated tendencies clip to clip. Due to political grounds, really small of program L-3 was implemented but three out of four proposals in the theodolite program were implemented.

Case Study 2: “ Fruitvale Transit Village Project the Unity Council, Bay Area Rapid Transit District, City of Oakland ”


The Fruitvale community located in Oakland is chiefly a low-income Latino vicinity holding a bulk of Afro-american and Asiatic populations. Community development corporation ( CDC ) formed in 1964 which worked on concern related to Fruitvale ‘s Latino community, came up with the thought of Fruitvale Transit Village.

Initially, multi-level parking garage was proposed on the site nearby the Fruitvale Bay country Rapid Transit ( BART ) in the twelvemonth 1991.The community people opposed the proposal since they thought that the undertaking would non be good for the community particularly from economic point of view. Rather, they suggested a undertaking which could make “ a more pedestrian-friendly ambiance between the station and the nearby commercial territory ” ( Fruitvale Transit Village Project ) and which would assist in advancing local concerns. BART had to retreat the undertaking and eventually accepted the community ‘s proposal, and worked with a local community development corporation ( Unity Council ) . In 1999, they came up with a mixed-used development program which cost around $ 100 million. The Unity Council in a partnership with BART has been engaged in using for grants and been doing community engagement in undertaking planning and design.


The chief issue on the multi-level parking proposal was on its location. Although parking was required in the vicinity, the community did non hold upon the proposal since the new installation would increase traffic congestion and was non environmentally sound for the vicinity.

Stake holders:

The stakeholders were Bay Area Rapid Transit District ( BART ) , Community development corporation ( CDC ) known as Unity Council, and City of Oakland..

Procedure and Role of Stakeholders:

Harmonizing to federal main road disposal website the Unity Council was engaged in using for the grants for be aftering undertakings. In February 1992, Unity council received $ 185,000 as Community Block Grant ( CDBG ) financess from City of Oakland to get down procedure of community planning for regenerating the country around Fruitvale BART station. For first two old ages, stakeholders worked on visioning and planning procedure, which started origin of thought for Fruitvale Transit Village. Their community engagement scheme was appreciated and subsequently awarded $ 470,000 FTA planning grant in 1993 by the US DOT for Fruitvale Transit Village ( Fruitvale Village Project Overview ) .

Identified Subject:

The chief aim of the undertaking was to function community by supplying such installations which could make easy handiness and propinquity to and from the vicinity and would keep better environment.

Public Involvement in program devising:

Unity council organized workshops in which around 30 people showed up. The chief aim of the undertaking was to assist community make the consensus, to acknowledge positive and negative facets of Fruitvale Community and therefore to assist the council place their development penchants. The consequence was rather productive. Participants identified assorted issues predominating in the community such as offense issue, scarce on retail concern and community services, the community ‘s negative image and eventually deficiency of connectivity between BART station and community. As a consequence, Unity Council Plan came up with the thought of mixed-used development which incorporated lodging, stores, office, library, a kid attention installation, prosaic place and other community services environing BART station. The strength of the undertaking was its community engagement which drove the undertaking further. Series of workshop were conducted and community engagement increased with every following workshops. The initial stage of the workshops was chiefly to acquire the feedback of the community about the programs designed by contrivers. In the undermentioned workshops, participants were asked to supply feedback on two alternate land usage programs prepared by the undertaking design squad based on community ‘s public assistance. This sort of pattern helped the council know the community ‘s vision towards theodolite station and its encompassing country.


The concluding undertaking constituents of Fruitvale Transit Village were to apportion the development on a nine acre parking batch of bing BART station- the site next to station. The development around the BART station includes lodging, retails, societal service bureaus and other commercial activities. The focal point of complex would be an elegant, tree lined prosaic place which connects the entryway of BART station with 12th street concern territory. The place would be accompanied by eating houses and stores which would hike assorted activities such festivals, concerts, etc.

Execution and challenges:

Although there was considerable advancement in planning and designing of Fruitvale Transit, the undertaking encountered assorted hurdlings. One of the major issues was the ownership of the packages. The whole batch was owned by BART. The job was there was an entrenched policy within the bureau to keep ownership of land within the immediate locality of belongings locations that are considered for theodolite Stationss. The purpose of the policy was to guarantee those belongingss could be enforcedly assigned land utilizations based on the long term program for the land and transportation would, by definition, transportation development rights. However, Unity Council required that BART make an exclusion to this policy and reassign this belongings at just market monetary value. BART agreed to make this dealing of barter of the belongings for a package owned by Fruitvale Policy commission behind the station and a figure of packages owned by the City of Oakland. This flexibleness on policy by BART was nailed by looker-ons. The 2nd barrier to the undertaking was the policy of BART to necessitate equal replacing of parking musca volitanss that are removed by any peculiar undertaking. To intercede the loss proposed by new undertaking Unity council contributed in dialogue of understanding with brotherhood Pacific station situated west of station. Finally, Unity Council used request in City of Oakland for alteration of districting regulation to censor building of any other parking infinite within the small town to cut down traffic congestion, enhance air quality and reference a prosaic friendly environment of Transit Village. Fruitvale Transit Village has set an illustration of theodolite oriented development in lower income interior metropolis community when theodolite oriented development has been successful chiefly in flush suburban locations.

Compare and contrast

Undertaking Definition:

Undertaking definition in the first instance survey of Chicago Area Transportation Study is to fix Transportation Plan for future. It was started in 1955 and took seven old ages to finish. The aim was to fix program for future growing and theodolite installations to accomplish end of greater velocity, increased safety, lower operation cost, economic system in new building, minimising break, and advancing better land development. Where as in another instance survey of Fruitvale Transit small town undertaking the undertaking definition was economic development of community by theodolite oriented development with a vision to elate the economically weak and minority vicinity next to BART station.

Planing Procedure:

In the first instance survey, CATS uses full reason in planning and demonstrates that rational theoretical account is feasible. Harmonizing to Plummer “ nucleus study was an attempt that involved home interviews of 1 out of every 30 families in the survey country. The 57,000 interviews provided a comprehensive individual twenty-four hours log of travel for these families. Another major travel study involved roadside interviews conducted on the margin of the survey country to find the travel in, out and through the country. Separate truck and cab studies were completed, along with a alone study of the public and private theodolite travel. ” ( Plummer, 2005 )

They produced a usher which was used by policy shapers for several old ages. CATS was a big planning bureau with ample of resources and was independent of bureaucratism. There was no public engagement involved at any phase of procedure. Not many be aftering bureaus get such type of chance. So this was comprehensive attack where they looked at metropolitan country as system whole. Planners were the ultimate determination shapers during the procedure. In this procedure they looked at the past tendencies to project the farther developments and type of urban signifier which would be determined by transit web. The procedure of planning is proficient and quantitative and it involved past tendencies and informations analysis for foretelling future land usage and traffic projection.

Second instance survey of Fruitvale Transit Village was advocacy planning procedure at the vicinity or community degree. Harmonizing to Federal Highway website this is a good illustration of public engagement, the creative activity of partnerships to get the better of legal, fiscal, and regulative hurdlings ; and the usage of public theodolite as a force for regenerating an interior metropolis community ( Fruitvale Village Project Overview ) . Fruitvale is chiefly low income minority community who are underprivileged group where BART proposed multi degree parking next to BART station based on their long scope program to suit the parking demand. CDC opposed the proposal of multilevel parking and advocated for the vision of more pedestrian-friendly ambiance of the Fruitvale community. The whole planning procedure was a political and full of community engagement at every degree. By series of workshops CDC helped community to put their ends and aims. There was strong engagement during this procedure of planning and that is reflected from the figure of participants during the workshops.

Planing Results:

In instance of Chicago Area Transportation Study based on the 10 measure rational attack, given several options for main road and theodolite webs in which 1 was selected by the sponsoring bureaus and determination shapers. CATS position was consultative and had nil to make with execution. In instance of Fruitvale Transit Village, during the execution procedure CDC played of import function in “ coordination and creative activity of partnerships to get the better of legal, fiscal, and regulative hurdlings ” ( Fruitvale Village Project Overview ) to see the community vision come true. Fruitvale was converted into the existent undertaking for the occupants of this vicinity as the first low income vicinity to holding theodolite oriented development. With the aid of Unity council, BART constructed parking garage on the belongings of Union Pacific Rail route situated west of station


The documents chiefly discuss two instance surveies for two different attacks in different epochs. In my position both procedures are right in their topographic point as they talk about success narratives for both parts. As mentioned in the two paradigms the rise of two theories were merchandise of their clip. In my position taking peculiar planning attack is besides circumstantial. Assorted be aftering paradigms have evolved over the period from the beginning of 1900 boulder clay alteration of century. The attack to peculiar issue of be aftering besides depends on the values, constructs and perceptual experience of the Planner.

The instance survey of Chicago Area Transportation Studies is done in rational comprehensive attack. Harmonizing to Black, reason in be aftering which continues to be affair of argument. Critic of rational theoretical account does non propose that contriver should be irrational, but they question about reason of theoretical account and compare it with Utopian phantasy. Besides it is easier to transport out rational planning procedure if the bureau is independent and have ample of financess, but to impact the determination doing contrivers they may hold to affect in political relations and forfeit reason to some grade.

In 2nd instance survey of Fruitvale Transit small town CDC advocated for the community demands, ends and aims. It helped the community to oppose the location of parking batch next to BART station and supported underrepresented community. CDC helped community to form themselves, acquire grants and financess for successful completion of the Transit oriented development. It besides helped BART to acquire new land for building of the garage. So in a manner this was a win-win state of affairs for all of stakeholders.

In planning, I think there is no individual manner of nearing the issue so knowledge of all paradigms enables us to understand the state of affairs and context in which they were used and germinate our ain theory to pattern every bit successful contriver. I have truly enriched myself from this term paper and have made my values and constructs of be aftering clear and have shown me the manner to near issues in planning. It has besides helped me to form my cognition of be aftering so far through assorted undertaking experiences and classs and shown me way to near profession.