An Illusion for the Masses Essay

“Patriotism is the last safety of the villain. ”

So said eighteenth Century British author Samuel Johnson. One can get down to believe about nationalism in its many signifiers but still arrive at the same occasion. it is merely people’s need to aline themselves with a larger individuality. This larger individuality could run from a vicinity to a athleticss squad to a state. Finding security. seeking pleasance. are. in my low sentiment. the most basic of human motivations. which nationalism helps indulge. It evokes a sense of belonging. transfusing the semblance of safety among a mass. Patriotism in its present signifier. certainly. is a human concept. True. it could be argued that it is derived from the aboriginal wont of being territorial. but territorialism has ne’er truly reached the giddying highs or ( depending on how you look at it ) the dismaying deepnesss of nationalism. What does it intend to be loyal? Amman Madan. writes in the aftermath of the immensely violent Godhra public violences. “Today when the burnt tonss in Gujarat are still smoldering. when Ayodhya promises to catch fire any twenty-four hours. it is necessary to analyze a cardinal inquiry: what is nationalism? Where make its roots lie? ” ( Madan. Para 1 )

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!


order now

The dictionary definition of the term covers all manners of wickednesss — devoted love. support. and defense mechanism of one’s state ; national trueness. With the gross sum of intensions both political and emotional attached to that word. one is bound to be confused whether it is absolute naivety on the general public’s portion or a ample ball of cynicism on mine. After more than 60 old ages of independency one feels the demand to rethink and redefine nationalism. is it a mark of trueness to the state or a misused sentiment? In a really direct yet in a apparently delusory manner. patriotism is by all respects. an semblance. I use the word semblance in relation to nationalism in the actual sense that it is a tool wielded by many a operators to act upon and pervert an waxy head into making their command.

In his seminal talk “Is Patriotism a Virtue? ” Alasdair Macintyre contrasts nationalism with the broad committedness to certain cosmopolitan values and rules. He states that Patriotism is non the thought of lovingfighting for one’s state. It is but merely. “A trueness to a peculiar state which merely those possessing that nationality can hold. ” He goes on to speak about how “patriotism is a non a virtuousness because it is non to judge organize an impersonal point of view. An impersonal point of view involves judging independently of one’s ain involvements. fondnesss. and societal place. In this. one must abstract oneself from specialness and fondness. ”

In modern times nationalism is frequently used out of context or in a convolutedly romanticised manner. The Jihad. the American “War on Terror” . the Arab -Israeli struggle. The Indo-Pak struggle and many other current scenarios are an consequence of a ( normally ) misplaced sense of nationalism nowadays in big pockets throughout the administration. which is once more exploited by their several political caputs.

While plowing through pages of information on nationalism online for this paper. I found a instead confusing article on a apparently guiltless web site titled “India Parenting” ; the article was titled “Do You Instil Patriotism in Your Children? ” It `goes on to state that “Children have to be told the significance of their state. Otherwise. they are bound to turn up without any particular fond feelings for their state. Such subject helps to determine them into responsible citizens” . However. it fails to province anyplace in the article as to how precisely one is supposed to believe that cognizing the national anthem. or the day of the month of independency makes one socially responsible. When looking at nationalism it is particularly of import to separate it from patriotism. India as a “nation” ne’er existed before August 15. 1947. so the construction of patriotism. as we know it today. began merely since. The nationalism that existed pre-independence was one fuelled by a desire to free India of the British Raj.

What composes today’s nationalism. with insignia like the National Flag and the National Anthem? Can watercourse of fictile imitation flags which are shortly strewn across the school resort area or discarded in ashcans be symbols of India? ( Rajagopal. H. Para 3 ) “Nothing could be more black than for nationalism to go established with the faith of a state. ” ( Eastman. Para 1 ) Written in 1917. these prophetic words were horrifically realized during the Partition of the Sub-Continent. In a twosome of months in the summer of 1947. stopping point to a million people were slaughtered on both sides in the spiritual rioting. all in the name of two distinguishable states for different faiths. This disruptive clip blurred the line irreversibly between faith and nationalism in the sub -continent. to this twenty-four hours quite a big ball of spiritual slurs that are hurled around are basically contriv erectile dysfunction signifiers of an “anti-national” or frailty versa.

Patriotism. over clip has acquired a just portion of critics including Russian novelist and mind Leo Tolstoy. who is celebrated to hold stated that nationalism: “ . . Is stupid because every nationalist holds his ain state to be the best of all whereas. evidently. merely one state can measure up. It is immoral because it enjoins us to advance our country’s involvements at the disbursal of all other states and by any agencies. including war. and is therefore at odds with the most basic regulation of morality. which tells us non to make to others what we would non desire them to make to us”

I find myself being really doubting of people. or “patriots” who say they would decease for their state. it’s of import non to misconstrue me at this occasion. I do non intend to trivialize the 1000000s that have died. but my job with that statement is a simple one. We worlds are. quintessentially. selfish and we invariably seek pleasance or personal addition. so the thought of one’s profound forfeit for one’s state merely for the improvement of one’s “nation” is a instead unelaborated one. There is ever that malodor of a underhand subterranean motivation behind seeking martyrdom. it could be the promise of 7 virgins waiting in Eden to carry through one’s phantasies or even merely the enticement of possible immortality associated with a decease. “Men volitionally believe what they wish. ” ( Caesar. Julius )

It is the self- psychotic belief that they indulge themselves in. invariably concealing beneath the wide streamer of nationalism is something that doesn’t truly work for me. Basically. I’m stating that one needn’t attempt to gull themselves and others ( nevertheless romantic it may sound ) of their motivations. merely expression at it for what it truly is. it is all but merely another canonized manner to acquire what you want. The vastly successful ( and one might even hold the cheek to state loyal ) General George S. Patton. in all his honestness. is celebrated to hold said. “The object of war is non to decease for your state but to do the other asshole dice for his. ”

Bibliography

Macintyre. Alasdair. “Is Patriotism a Virtue? ” ( The Lindley Lecture ) . of Kansas. Reprinted in Primoratz ( ed. ) ( 2002 ) .

Lawrence: University

Madan. Amman. “What is Patriotism? ” The Hindu. April ( 2002 ) : 7 Tolstoy. Leo and “Patriotism. or Peace? ”
Society hypertext transfer protocol: //www. salsa. net/peace/conv/8weekconv7-3. hypertext markup language.

Philadelphia: New

India Parenting. “Do You Instil Patriotism in Your Children? ” . 8-03-11 hypertext transfer protocol: //www. indiaparenting. com/raisingchildren/253_1357/do-you-instill-patriotism-in-your-children. hypertext markup language Rajagopal. Harini. “Patriotism: an alternate view” The Hindu Online. September 01. 2001http: //www. hinduonnet. com/2001/09/01/stories/13011106. htm 15-03-11 Eastman. Max. “The Religion of Patriotism” . Marxist. July 1917 hypertext transfer protocol: //www. Marxists. org/history/etol/writers/eastman/works/1910s/patriot. htm 15-03-01